I’m becoming a consumer voter. An
entitled taxpayer. A “What’s in it for me?” citizen.
I never thought the day would come.
But as I peruse each party’s platform
this election, I find myself examining them purely in self-interest, like I’m
scanning a menu at Tim Horton’s.
Hmmm… income splitting is certainly
good for my single-income family – I’ll take one of those.
The Canada Child Benefit looks
okay…. Probably richer than the universal child care benefit. Give me two.
Oh, I have to have two kids?
Okay, one is fine.
Fifteen-dollar-a-day daycare looks interesting
but not relevant to me… I’ll pass.
Home renovation tax credit? Terrible public policy, but yes, I’ll take that
as well.
And so on it goes. The politicians have created a new suite of
goodies for the middle class. They’ve
come up with a host of tax credits and subsidies that funnel your taxes back into
your pocket. Do you deserve it? Of course you do!
Our society has become so
consumer-oriented and lethargic, in some cases, that these are the only things
keeping us interested in way-too-long election campaign.
One could take the perspective that this
is simply a reflection of our country’s stability. While some countries have real issues to deal
with, like whether or not to declare bankruptcy, we’re debating whether we want a home
improvement tax credit or a bigger monthly cheque for our child’s activities. Yes, it’s tough to be a Canadian.
Just ask my nephew from Ukraine, who’s
willing to leave everything behind for the opportunity to work and live in
Canada. He’ll tell you we have nothing
to worry about. No wars, no economic
collapse, no political upheaval. “It’s
Can-A-da” he likes to say (with special emphasis on the “a”) when commenting on
the many trivial issues we like to debate.
Now if he can just jump through the many
hoops of our immigration system, he’ll be readier than many Canadians to
contribute to our society.
So the good news is we’re doing
pretty good here in Canada. The bad news
is these election goodies can create a short-sighted approach to our future. Whether it’s growing the economy or action on
climate change, our focus becomes misplaced on what we can gain from the system
today.
And with each of these mini-tax breaks
comes a cost, both bureaucratic and economic. If tax breaks are really what
citizens want, why not just lower income tax rates and let people spend on what
they want and need? Or put the money into public programs that
work but require greater funding.
Despite four years of significant
federal cutbacks, budget deficits and a current economic downturn, all leaders
are acting like we’re awash in cash. If
we took the time to actually cost out the goodies, we might just realize that
our funds could be spent better elsewhere or maybe not at all.
And we might even turn our attention
to bigger things... like whether the Blue Jays can make a run for the World Series. Hey, even I'm back on that bandwagon.
Lower taxes benefit the rich, as they get to keep even more of the wealth. And, yes, go Blue Jays!
ReplyDelete